The Euro End Game

Walter Russell Mead neatly sums up the dilemma facing Germany:

Northern governments may only now be waking up to the deep cynicism with which some southern governments are approaching the crisis.  Neither the Greeks nor the Italians have anything but moral contempt for German and Nordic financial puritanism.  They see the northern banks (and bank regulators) as equally to blame for the crisis, and they have in no way lost their national egoism.  They are debating in European forums today with the same nationalist selfishness that their predecessors did 150 years ago.  They will play every card in their hands — and the fact that an Italian collapse certainly and a Greek collapse quite probably would wreck the whole European economy gives them quite a few cards.

The Germans in fact have been thoroughly hornswoggled and despite all their humping and grumping, they are going to pay through the nose.  They can pay in the form of massive bailouts and subsidies as long as southern Europeans want northern money, or they can pay in the form of a continental financial crash, the mother of all EU political crashes, and years of bitter ill will throughout Europe.  Chancellor Kohl walked into a French trap on the euro, and the trap has sprung on Chancellor Merkel.

There is zero, repeat, zero sign that the Germans specifically or the Europeans as a whole have figured out what to do, much less agreed on a plan for getting it done.  Will Germany gnaw off its leg to escape from the euro trap, or will it allow the French to bind it forever in a transfer union in which thrifty and punctual German ants will subsidize Latin and Greek grasshoppers?

It is honestly hard at this point to say which alternative is worse for both Germany and Europe.  Is it better to have a sullen Germany yoked to a Europe that cheats it, or to go through a massive crash followed, one suspects, by a powerful and selfish Germany, a bitter, poor and unstable Club Med — and a scheming, jealous France?

This looks more and more like the choice Europe must make, and the biggest question is whether European leaders can make a decisive choice before events make the choice for them.

Too assume that the citizens of Greece, Spain, Italy, Portugal and maybe even France are going to quietly adopt Germanic discipline as a condition of rescue is folly. Unless the German’s have calculated that a collapse of the Euro would be more unendurable than financing the social welfare system of these basket cases one should probably be preparing for the financial crisis that we dodged a couple of years ago.

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Leave a Reply