Obama And The Creative Class

Joel Kotkin has an interesting take on the winners in the wake of Barack Obama’s victory. His contention is that the election marks the ascendancy of the so-called “creative class. The economic impact that he projects from this thesis is interesting.

He argues that Obama enjoyed immense support both in terms of voter turnout and, probably more importantly, financial support from the post-industrial sector of the economy. At the same time, Kotkin contends that the traditional economic power bases have lost their standing and power to influence events as a result of the economic catastrophe.

Today the traditional business leadership, like their Republican allies, present a spectacle of utter disarray. The commercial banks have been effectively nationalized. Many traditional manufacturers, notably automakers, also yearn to suck on the federal teat. Reduced to supplicants, these companies have surrendered their standing as independent players. At the same time, the traditional energy companies, long the whipping boys of Congressional Democrats, will be fully occupied trying to survive the onslaught of anti-carbon regulations now all but inevitable.

Hard to argue with that contention. But it is his extrapolation of the affects of the increased power of the creative class to its impact on the economy that is of interest.

What will this ascendancy mean in economic terms? Since the creative class deals largely with images, ideas and transactions, it’s not likely to focus much on reviving the tangible parts of the economy: manufacturing, logistics, traditional energy and agribusiness.

On the other hand, the creatives are unlikely to be protectionist since they represent companies whose growth markets, and often suppliers, are located overseas. Heavily counted among the world’s richest people, they are also likely to support some Bushite policies–like low interest rates and financial bailouts–that prop up their stock prices and drive money to Wall Street.

The biggest difference between the creative class and the old business types isn’t on cultural issues–few traditional CEOs embraced the religious right’s agenda–but on environmental policy. Executives at places like Apple, as well as opportunistic investment firms, have become enthusiastic jihadis in the war against climate change. Conveniently, their companies don’t tend to be huge energy consumers and, if they make products, do so in largely unregulated facilities in China or elsewhere in the developing world. And youthful financial firms looking for the next “bubble” could benefit hugely from mandates for more solar, wind and other alternative fuels.

All this could prove very bad news for groups that produce tangible products in the U.S. or that, like large agribusiness firms, are big consumers of carbon. Also threatened will be anyone who builds the suburban communities–notably single-family houses and malls–that most Americans still prefer but that Gore and his acolytes dismiss as too energy-intensive, not to mention in bad taste.

Theoretically, there is opportunity for the Republicans–if they can somehow jettison the more primitive parts of their social agenda and come up with their own bold, environmentally sound energy agenda. The new hegemons could easily be painted as moralistic hypocrites who live the carbon-heavy luxury lifestyle of the super-rich while demanding ordinary Americans give up their cars, homes and even their jobs.

Kotkin is perhaps focusing too narrowly on the carbon issue. Granted it is going to be a profound argument in the coming years and the affects of decisions made are going to reshape the economy but I think that there are other factors which may lessen the power Kotkin sees flowing to the new group of power brokers.

The Democrats are deeply in debt to the unions. Their agenda differs markedly from that of the “creative class” and squaring that circle will be a challenge. Overriding this, however, is the issue that to my mind may well trump all others. Specifically the growing problem of income inequality.

I am a late comer to believing that this issue was anything more than Democratic sloganeering. A bit of reading and some research has convinced me that indeed it is an issue and one which might get much worse much more quickly than anyone imagines. The economic crisis and long term contraction of credit is going to pull one of the major props out from underneath the middle class. Heretofore, the availability of credit has served to mask the income gap and deliver to the middle class the goods that they have been led to believe they must have. Take credit and thus access to those things away and the starkness of the division becomes abundantly clear.

If the majority of the country finds itself on the outside looking in at a precious few who enjoy unfathomable wealth then that majority will become quite restive quite quickly. Obama and the Democrats will have their hands full if they don’t move to address this issue.

Tom Lindmark

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

47 Responses to “Obama And The Creative Class”

  1. Bước 7: Các bạn bấm New để tạo chữ ký mới.

  2. Chúng các bạn tìm được 1 công ty uy tín.

  3. Anh says:

    Ԝow! This could be one partіcular οf the most beneficial blοgs We’ve eѵer arrive across on this subject.
    Basicaⅼly Excellеnt. I’m also a specіalist in this topic therefore I can understand your effort.

    Feel frwe to suiгf to my website … see here now (Anh)

  4. cgs-monza.it says:

    Way cool! Einige sehr extrem gültige Punkte!
    Ich schätze Sie Penning Diese Zuschreibung plus Reest der Webseite exttem
    wirklch gut.

  5. Hi, this weeken is good for me, since this pooint in time i am reading this great educational post here aat my home.

    Look aat my site; led strip light extension cable

  6. wmql888.com says:

    Wenn Siee Wunsch biss wachsen Vertraulichkeit nur halten Besuch dieswer Website Website und aktualisier werden,
    der Beliebtheit up-to-date Klatsch hier gepostet.

  7. Maricela says:

    Finne way of describing, and pleasant post to take information on tthe tlpic of my presentation subject matter, which i am going to present in school.

    Feel free to visit my web page – led headlight
    for car (Maricela)

  8. Anneliese says:

    Es ist ein bemerkenswerte Artikel konzipiert alle Internet Zuschauer; sie nehmen erhalten Nutzen von ihm bin ich mir
    sicher.

  9. a says:

    I pay a quick visit day-to-day some web sites and blogs to read articles or reviews,
    however this blog provides quality based writing.

  10. Octavia says:

    Hallo, ich denke, dass ichh sah, ddie Sie besucht mein wbsite so i kam ich “revanchieren”.
    Veresuch zzu finden, um die Dinge zuu verbessern verbessern mein Ich nehhme an, es ist ok, um einige verwenden Ihre Ideen !!

  11. Lenard says:

    hallo! Ich mag Ihren Schreib so eine Menge!
    Anteil Kojmunikation mehr rund Ihre Post auf AOL?
    I Notwendigkeit Experte über diese space zu lösen mein Problem.
    Kann sdin das ist Sie! Suche vor schauen Sie.

  12. a says:

    Amazing! Its really amazing paragraph, I have got much clear
    idea about from this article.

  13. Brianna says:

    Herzlichen Gruß! Sehhr nützlich in diesem besonddren post!
    Es istt ddie die wichtigsten Änderungen. Danke für ddas Teilen!

  14. Ola says:

    Hallo, Ich fühle mich i dzmit so i bemerkte besucht Sie meinen kam zu Rück
    der wählen Ich?. versuchen zu finden Dinge zzu verbessern verbessern mein Website Ich gehe davon! ok zu verwwenden einige von Ihre
    Ideen !!

  15. a says:

    Hey there I am so thrilled I found your web site, I really found you by error, while
    I was researching on Google for something else, Anyways I am here now and would just
    like to say cheers for a fantastic post and a
    all round enjoyable blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to read it all
    at the minute but I have bookmarked it and also included your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read more,
    Please do keep up the excellent job.

  16. a says:

    I think what you said was very logical. However, what about
    this? what if you were to create a killer post title?

    I mean, I don’t wish to tell you how to run your blog, however suppose you added something
    that makes people desire more? I mean Obama And The Creative Class | But Then What is kinda boring.

    You might glance at Yahoo’s home page and watch how they create news
    titles to grab viewers to open the links. You might try adding a video
    or a related pic or two to get readers excited about what you’ve written.
    Just my opinion, it might make your posts a little bit more interesting.

  17. aolrdee.com says:

    Unglaubliche! Dieser Blog siieht gennau gerade wiie medin alter!

    Es ist auf einbem vollständig , aber es hat ziemlich die gleiche Layout
    und Design. Große Wahl der Farben!

  18. Improves memory, reduces the results of oxidation.

  19. Fine way of telling, and nice paragraph too gget
    data about my presentation subect matter, whicch i am going
    to convey in academy.

    My blogg post: Smoke damage Cleanup

  20. The bees that this Ovimbundu hive are Cyprian in type, much like the Italian bees
    found in America about size, but with shorter tongues and shorter tempers.
    It also protects the skin from the damage caused by the UV rays of
    the sun – the greatest element in age spot formation. Another wonderful thing about this part of modeling is the fact that almost always
    there is going to be some work to be had.

  21. When nothing negative is discovered, there’s a green circle with a examine
    mark inside it beside every search.

  22. Numbers says:

    Destroy 4 or five enemy autos in a single battle.

  23. Lakeisha says:

    Generally I do not read article on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very compelled me to try and do it!
    Your writing taste has been surprised me.
    Thanks, very great post.

  24. etnzn.com says:

    Ich mag, was euhh sund in der Regel bis zu. Diese Art der exposure!
    Halten Sie sicch die hervorragende ausgezeichneten funktioniert Jungs Ich habe enthalten euch
    zu unsere Blogroll.

  25. hire minibus says:

    Temp employment agencies…

    Obama And The Creative Class | But Then What…

  26. Soon says:

    Destroy 4 or five enemy vehicles in a single battle.

  27. Winston says:

    Was ist Nachrichten ich bin neu iin diesem, stieß ich auff diese Ich habe entdekte Es absolut geholfen und es hat dwzu beigetragen,
    gestützte mich Lasten. Ich hoffe bis Beitragg & Hilfe aandere Benutzer
    wwie ihre geholfen me. Groß Arbeit.

  28. Ralph says:

    Vielen Dannk für die gute Dokument. Es waar in der Tat ein Freizeitkonto
    ist. Schauen fortgeschritten wweit angnehm vvon Ihnen hinzugefügt!

    Allerdings Wiie konhte kommunizieren wir?

  29. Alfred says:

    Ich bin nicht mehr sicher, der Orrt Siee bekommen Siie
    Ihre Informationen, aber ggood Thema. I muss verbriingen einige Zeit herauszufiden viel mehr oder Verständnis mehr.
    Vielen Dank für ausgezeichnete info Ich wwar auuf der Suche nach diess Infos
    für meinee Mission.

  30. Katja says:

    Woah! Ich bin wirklich ieb die Vorlage / Thena dieses blog.
    Es ist einfach, aberr effektiv. Eine Menge Zeit, es
    ist sehr schwer, hartenn zu bekommen, dass “perfekten Balance” zwischen Usability und Optik.

    Ich muss sagen, dass Sie haben, Sie haben eine fantastischen Areit
    mit diesem. Zusätzlich, die Blog Lastrn sehr Schnell für mich auf Chrom.
    Superb Blog

  31. Hildegarde says:

    And, as a result of no two women’s our bodies are alike,
    we are proud to boast an unequalled collection of lovely ladies’s plus measurement coats and leather jackets.

  32. Lucia says:

    Ryan Handlarski – Toronto Felony Defence Lawyer.

  33. Delbert says:

    Faye began performing in grownup films in 2007.

  34. Einee Person Wesentlichen Hand anleegen um erheblich Artikel
    Ich könnte Zustand . Dies ist Das ist die erste allererste Mal,
    dass ich besucht Ihre website page und bislang? I
    überrascht mit Forschung Siee gemacht machen diese besondere Post unglaubliche.
    Wunder Job!

  35. Almeda says:

    Selling fanart of copyrighted heroes? Few
    corporations would want to draw in bad publicity
    by seeking those who are followers, especially if the function does not
    detract from their function. But that does not mean they cannot.
    There is a tacit knowing that low-level, non-detractive fan art will appear and even be offered, but that will not
    mean that… display more why

  36. a says:

    Good post. I learn something new and challenging on blogs I stumbleupon every
    day. It’s always helpful to read articles from other authors and practice a
    little something from their web sites.

  37. Thanks for any other excellent post. The place else could anybody get that type of
    info in such an ideal method of writing? I have a presentation next week, and
    I’m at the look for such info.

  38. a says:

    Hey, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your blog site in Ie, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer,
    it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick
    heads up! Other then that, excellent blog!

  39. Marc says:

    Haolo wollte Ihnwn einenn schnellen Heads-up geben. Die Wortfe in Ihrren Poost scheinen auss deem Bildschirm in Lauuf Safari.
    Ich bin nicht sicher, ob dies eein Formatierung Ausgabe oder etwas mit Internet-Browser
    tun Kompatibilität, aber ich dachte, dachte, ich würde schreiben, umm Ihnen mitzuteilen. Derr design gut aussehen aber!
    Hoffe, Sie bwkommen das Problem Thema Fest bald. Prost

  40. Margarette says:

    Hallo, ich denke, daass ich sah, die Sie besucht mein Website somit i Ich bin “revanchieren”.
    Versuch zu zu finden, um die Dinge zu verbessern verbessern mein Ich nehme an, es ist ok,
    um einige verwenden Ihhre Ideen !!

  41. Jorge says:

    Goodd Informationen. Glück für mic fand ich Ihre Webste zufällig (stumbleupon).
    Ichh habe Buch-Kennzeichnung it für später!

  42. sell my vacant house…

    Obama And The Creative Class | But Then What…

  43. Sadye says:

    Vielen Dank für die verheißungs Dokument. Es war in der Tat ein Freizeitkonto ist.
    Schauen fortgeschritten mehr angenehm vvon Ihnen hinzugefügt!
    Übrigens Wie konnte kommunizieren wir?

  44. Es ist sehr problemlose, jede heruszufinden Them uum neet gegenüber Bücher, wie ich fand diese
    Stück Schreiben an diessem Website.

  45. Rodney says:

    Sehhr gute Informationen. Glück für mich Vor kurzem fand ich
    Ihre Website zufällig (stumbleupon). Ich habe alls Favoriit gesepeichert für später!

  46. Lace Wigs says:

    wigs online

    Obama And The Creative Class | But Then What

  47. a says:

    Thanks to my father who shared with me on the topic of this web site, this website is
    in fact awesome.

Leave a Reply